Please do not go by mere internet reviews. Many are skewed, biased, and often created by the surgeon and/or supporters of the surgeon.
Ask as many questions as possible on this forum, and be careful whose advice you heed. Even meeting "former" patients of surgeons can be tricky, as many are actors.
I would go with surgeon #1.
I am an unpaid volunteer super moderator. I receive no remuneration from this site. Although I am a medical professional, any recommendations, statements, advice, or opinions I provide are mine, and mine alone. Consult carefully with the medical professional of your choice. All statements, recommendations, opinions, and advice expressed by me are mine personally – independent of the site and made as a forum member only – and do not necessarily reflect those of PlasticSurgerySpot.com.