*update*
It's 6 months since my surg today. My tip/supra tip is kind of gushy/very soft and the tissue is really moving around now. Since the injection, I can actually push the "pollybeak" bump down pretty flat.
I had another doctor take a look at it. He told me about Pollybeak, so he does think it may be what I have (which I figured out myself, I might as well be a doctor

). He also thought he could feel a slight bit of cartilage sticking out that wasn't removed, beneath the scarring, that might need to be revised, but that it is hard to tell with the scar tissue still there.
This second doc also said I should wait for a while, or wait until I have more steroid treatments and when the swelling goes down so we can really tell what it actually looks like.
I have been smoking, you know, but I think it's ok because I notice the progression. I really hope I don't need more injections because it was not the most pleasant feeling to say the least...and needles gross me out :P