Welcome to the forum, anonymous_guy
I can't say that I personally know of any Indianapolis rhinoplasty surgeons. Would it be possible to expand your search to a wider area? Rhinoplasty is such a complicated procedure (that freequently comes with bad results) it's important to find a doctor that is at the top of his game. Now that's not to say there isn't one in Indiana, but I just don't want to see you limit yourself to such a small selection.
It also sounds like you may have some body dismorphic disorder going on. Do you really think when people walk by they are looking at your nose
To me that sounds like you have a distorted view of reality. Even where I live there are tons of people with deformed, large nosess and none of them make me do a doubletake. Do you really think in Indianapolis (the Midwest!) people are going to do that?